Overall, this is not a bad bill. I am not sure that awarding property rights to surface owners is necessary or wise (several states do so, but many foreign countries keep those as a public resource held and regulated by the government), but many of those details need to be sorted out in rule-making.
At this point, WVU has a project that may lead to geothermal development, but WV-DEP testified they were unaware of any other projects being considered in WV.
Note: Geothermal energy is partially the left-over heat from formation of Planet Earth, and partly the result of nuclear fission from elements deep within the Earth. I believe that nuclear energy with literally thousands of feet of rock shielding is safe, and I support its use as geothermal energy. Other forms of nuclear energy (specifically, commercial reactors at the surface) do not have that layer of safety.
Jim Kotcon
On Mon, Mar 14, 2022 at 11:16 PM Duane Nichols duane330@aol.com wrote:
*Full WV Senate to consider bill that would set up regulatory program for geothermal energy* | Legislative Session | wvgazettemail.com, Mike Tony, March 9, 2022
https://www.wvgazettemail.com/news/legislative_session/full-wv-senate-to-con...
*NOTE ~ WV Senate passed this HB 4098 on March 12, 2022. DGN*
The full West Virginia Senate will consider a bill that would set up a state regulatory program for geothermal energy.
The Senate Judiciary Committee on Tuesday advanced House Bill 4098, which would give the Department of Environmental Protection regulatory oversight of geothermal energy.
Geothermal energy is a renewable energy source within the Earth that is used to heat buildings and provide electricity.
HB 4098 would grant ownership rights to geothermal resources to the owner of surface property over the resource unless severance of the geothermal resource is clear in documentation conveying ownership of it.
The bill requires the DEP to create a permitting system for geothermal development for which it must establish temperature levels and volumetric flow rates. The legislation would make the agency responsible for establishing rules for geothermal drilling and site reclamation — including proper plugging — after a well no longer is used.
West Virginia University geothermal research plans prompted the bill.
House Energy and Manufacturing Committee counsel Robert Akers previously told the committee, which was first to approve the bill, that a permit for the university is the only one that would be pending initially under a new geothermal regulatory program.
HB 4098 would allow the DEP to issue civil penalties ranging from $100 to $500 for each violation of rules established under the bill, and take civil action against violators in any circuit court where a well is located for injunctive relief.
The House Judiciary Committee previously amended the bill to exclude geothermal heating and cooling heat pump systems for private residential dwellings and farm buildings from DEP jurisdiction.
The Senate Judiciary Committee amended the bill to make technical changes. Lawmakers intend for the bill to apply to wells thousands of feet underground.
Samuel Taylor, assistant director of strategic partnerships and technology at the WVU Energy Institute, handed out PowerPoint slides to Energy and Manufacturing Committee members in January. The slides showed that Northern West Virginia could be a potential “hot spot” for geothermal energy.
A map on one slide showed patches of Earth in the region hotter than most of the rest of the Eastern United States.
Another slide noted that geothermal could be a popular alternative energy source as companies with local footprints, like Chemours and Dow, strive to meet company-set carbon dioxide emission-reduction goals.
The university’s U.S. Department of Energy-funded project includes drilling and sampling a deep-exploratory well to a depth of 15,000 feet to validate subsurface temperatures, according to one of the PowerPoint slides from Taylor. The slide noted a focus of the project is to gauge the potential of heating the university campus using a geothermal resource.
West Virginia Environmental Council President Linda Frame said her organization supports the production of geothermal energy but stressed that it be done with minimal disruption to the environment and landowners.
xxx