Total Dissolved Solids in Monongahela River Drop
Significantly Below State, Federal Limits
DEP to Continue Monitoring Levels, Taking Samples
<LOCATION>, , <CHRO /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- The Department of
Environmental Protection confirmed today that levels of total dissolved solids, or TDS,
in the Monongahela River have dropped and remain well below state and
federal guidelines.
Three weeks of laboratory data on water samples from the river found TDS
levels below …
[View More]the 500 parts per million criteria established by the department
and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. The latest results from Three w
recorded levels ranging from 110 ppm to 196 ppm.
In comparison, lab results for water samples collected on In comp, when the
highest TDS levels were detected, ranged from 438 ppm to 908 ppm.
Unusually high TDS levels were first detected on Unusually high TDS le at
points along approximately 70 stream miles on the Monongahela River between the
at points al border and the confluence of the Youghiogheny and the
Monongahela rivers in , , <LOCATION>Allegheny .
By November, high TDS levels were detected as far north as "The By No" in "
in <LOCA, where the , meets the Allegheny River to form the Ohio River.
DEP will continue to monitor the United States Geological Survey river
gauges for conductivity, which is a far less expensive and time consuming
alternative to lab analyses. If conductivity levels increase significantly, DEP may
resume sampling.
In addition, DEP is working with water suppliers through the River Alert and
Information Network to develop a regional water quality monitoring system.
While elevated levels of TDS do not represent a major human health risk, TDS
can affect the taste and odor of drinking water. For that reason, secondary
maximum contaminant levels of 500 parts per million were established for the
commonwealth's drinking water and waterways.
TDS is a measure of all elements dissolved in water and can include
carbonates, chlorides, sulfates, nitrates, sodium, potassium, calcium and magnesium.
Sources of TDS can include abandoned mine drainage, stormwater runoff, waste
water from gas well drilling and discharges from industrial or sewage
treatment plants.
CONTACT:
Helen Humphreys
(412) 442-4183
**************From Wall Street to Main Street and everywhere in between, stay
up-to-date with the latest news. (http://aol.com?ncid=emlcntaolcom00000023)
[View Less]
The public is invited to attend a Sierra Club meeting on January 15th at
6:30 PM at Our Studio, 601D East Brockway. Directions are available at
www.ourstudio.org. We plan to watch a film about Mountain Top Removal called Mountain
Mourning and discuss conservation initiatives for WV. For further information
contact Sandy at 290-8733.
**************New year...new news. Be the first to know what is making
headlines. (http://news.aol.com?ncid=emlcntusnews00000002)
The River Of Filth
Half of Ohio River unfit to swim from fecal bacteria
>From Staff Reports, Wheeling Intelligencer, December 26, 2008.
WHEELING - West Virginia is working with five other states and the federal
government to clean up about 475 miles of the Ohio River that is sometimes
unfit for swimming because of sewage.
The Ohio River Valley Water Sanitation Commission analyzed more than 14,000
samples taken between Pittsburgh and Cairo, Ill., and found high fecal counts
…
[View More]following heavy rains along almost half of the 981-mile river.
The amount of harmful pathogens from sewage found in local samples of Ohio
River water exceeded acceptable limits many times in May, June and July and on
a few occasions in August, September and October. An average monthly level of
fecal coliform that is considered safe is 200/100 milliliters of water,
according to the study. For E. coli, a safe monthly average is listed at 130/100
milliliters.
But in May alone, levels of fecal coliform in samples taken at four local
points along the river all exceeded those safe monthly averages: At Pike Island,
the monthly average for May was 527/100 milliliters; at Warwood, 458/100
milliliters; at Wheeling, 701/100 milliliters; and at the Ohio-Marshall county
line, 894/100 milliliters.
The monthly May average for E.coli was much the same, with readings
including: Pike Island, 186/100 milliliters; Warwood, 178/100 milliliters; Wheeling,
124/100 milliliters; and the Ohio-Marshall county line, 544/100 milliliters.
Although the average amount of E. coli at Wheeling did fall within acceptable
limits, the fecal coliform level made the overall pathogen level
unacceptable.
Much of the sewage in the river came from treatment-plant overflows,
groundwater runoff from farms and slaughterhouses, and tanning, pulp and paper
factories, ORSANCO said.
Roughly 2,000 companies and municipalities have permits to discharge treated
wastewater into the Ohio River and its 130 tributaries. Problems occur when
heavy rains cause water flows to exceed treatment plants' capacity, allowing
untreated waste to flow into the river.
The Ohio provides drinking water to nearly 3 million people and is a major
transportation route. It also is a source for manufacturing and power
generation.
The commission is working with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and
Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Ohio, Pennsylvania and West Virginia to develop a
remediation plan required to meet water quality standards of the federal
Clean Water Act. Tetra Tech Inc. of Fairfax, Va., has been hired to provide
consulting services and help develop the plan by 2010.
Public hearings are scheduled next month in all six states.
**************One site keeps you connected to all your email: AOL Mail,
Gmail, and Yahoo Mail. Try it now.
(http://www.aol.com/?optin=new-dp&icid=aolcom40vanity&ncid=emlcntaolcom00000…)
[View Less]
State concerned about waste water from new gas wells
Sunday, December 21, 2008, By Don Hopey, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Gas well drillers tapping into the deep Marcellus Shales add up to 54 substances, some of them toxic,
to the water they use to fracture that rock and release the gas.
And the state Department of Environmental Protection doesn't know what chemicals, metals and possibly
radioactive elements are in the waste water that is pushed out of the wells. It is discharged into the …
[View More]state's
aterways including the Monongahela River, from which 350,000 people get their drinking water.
"That's the bigger issue. They don't have an analysis of what's in the waste water they're pulling out," said
Dr. Conrad Dan Volz, assistant professor in the Graduate School of Public Health at the University of
Pittsburgh. "What they're putting into the wells can chemically change and be added to underground,
and no one is saying how much arsenic, manganese, cobalt, chromium and lead is in the stuff.
Depending on the concentration, it could be a hazardous waste."
Each well drilled into the Marcellus Shales, which lie at least a mile deep beneath parts of Pennsylvania,
New York, West Virginia and Ohio, uses up to 4 million gallons of water to fracture the rock and release
natural gas. The chemicals are added to the "frac" water that is pumped into the wells under high
pressure to reduce friction in the pipe and allow the water to flow more freely into the rock layers.
Among the chemical additives are formaldehyde, a human carcinogen; various acids; a variety of
petroleum compounds and several pesticides that are toxic to fish and other aquatic life. Many
of the chemicals, depending on their concentrations, can also cause human skin, eye and nose
irritations, and damage kidney, heart, liver and lung function.
Much of that frac water -- about 40 percent of the total used -- is pushed back to the surface\
?by the gas released from the shale, and it must be disposed of.
"Yes, we're concerned," said Mark Hartle, chief of aquatic resources for the Pennsylvania Fish
and Boat Commission. "And we're more concerned with the recovered fluids from the wells than
?with the water they use to do the fracing initially. The problem is, we're not sure what they're
?ending up with so we don't know the constituents of the discharges."
Lou D'Amico, executive director of the Independent Oil & Gas Association of Pennsylvania,
said frac water chemical concentrations are low and treatment facilities are removing much
of the metals and dissolved solids from the waste water.
"Companies are committed to huge investments to treat the waste water, because without that
we're out of business," Mr. D'Amico said. "We're very aware of all the environmental and public
concerns, and our mission is to develop the Marcellus shale as an economic benefit to
Pennsylvania and in an environmentally sensitive way."
He said drilling and fracing companies are doing a wide-ranging survey of the waste water,
also known as "flow-back water," to show it is not a health hazard.
Tom Rathbun, a DEP spokesman, said the department also is doing a chemical analysis
of the waste water, a study that should be done by the first of the year.
"We have a general idea but want to know for sure," Mr. Rathbun said. "If it's different,
we will make the necessary adjustments. "I don't think they've been doing enough
Marcellus Shales drilling so far to make a difference," Mr. Rathbun said. "But the gas
industry needs to come up with a way to deal with this. A couple of companies want
to do on-site water treatment, and others are looking at different recycling technologies."
He said there are now only about 20 active Marcellus Shales gas wells. But there has
been drilling activity at more than 300 in Pennsylvania, and another 250 have been issued
state permits.
The drilling and water discharges have attracted the attention of the U.S. Environmental
Protection Agency.
"It is an issue that's been on our radar for a while and currently a matter we're looking into,"
said Dave McGuigan, associate director of EPA's regional office of permits and enforcement.
"The question is what is in [well waste water] and what are the treatment facilities doing with it."
Some of the waste water is taken to DEP-approved municipal sewer authorities that dilute it with
their regular effluent before discharging it into a river or stream. Some is trucked to one of the state's
six industrial water treatment facilities, where metals, oils and some dissolved solids are removed
but where waste salts are a disposal problem exacerbated by the volume of the waste water.
"The salts are the biggest issue right now and the most expensive thing to remove from the highly
concentrated brines," said Paul Hart, president of Pennsylvania Brine Treatment Inc., who owns
three of the state's six industrial treatment facilities and wants to build six more.
Mr. Hart criticized the DEP for slow action on permit applications for new treatment facilities,
for regulating the well water as waste, which limits the ability of drillers and treatment facilities
?to recycle it, and for failing to determine the composition of the waste water.
"The Marcellus has wide variations in the amount of iron, barium and salt, and we need to
know the high and low marks so we can treat it and we're still determining that," he said.
?"Right now we don't know as much as we'd like to know."
The drilling companies provide the DEP with lists of chemicals they add to the water
but not the amounts of specific mixtures, claiming that is proprietary information.
Four of the chemical compounds are complex pesticides that scientific assessments
have determined are "very toxic to fish." One, 2.2-Dibromo-3-nitrilopropionamide,
retards fetal development in rabbits.
The pesticides are added to the drill water to stop the growth of algae in temporary holding
?ponds and tanks built next to the drilling pads. Algae and other "biofilms" can foul pumps
used to push the water underground and into the shale.
None of those chemicals should be discharged directly into surface water such as the
Monongahela River, said Dr. Volz, who is studying the effects of pollutants in the rivers.
"If there's enough biocide to kill algae, by the looks of this bromated compound there's
enough to do damage to fish," Dr. Volz said. "Throwing it in the water is just crazy."
He said formaldehyde, which is a human carcinogen, "is always a concern," but any
risk is impossible to assess without knowing its concentration.
In addition to the pesticides, the chemicals added to the well "fracing" water include
acids to dissolve cement around the pipe casings and open perforations in the pipe
for the water to flow through and into the shale formation; friction reducers to make
pumping easier; and additives to keep clay from reducing the flow of the released gas.
Different pumping companies use different frac-fluid recipes and formulas and different
combinations and amounts of those chemicals.
A report on the chemical additives requested by DEP's Bureau of Oil & Gas Management
and prepared for the Independent Oil & Gas Association of Pennsylvania states that care
and controls are used to prevent the frac chemicals and chemical water solutions from
contaminating surface and ground water near the wells. The report also notes that water
in the Marcellus Shales contains high concentrations of dissolved solids, making it
unsuitable as a drinking, agricultural or industrial water supply.
The DEP and public water suppliers have said the high TDS levels are not a health
concern. But David Dzombeck, an environmental engineering professor at Carnegie
Mellon University, said without knowing the chemical composition of the dissolved
solids, that's hard to confirm.
Don Hopey can be reached at 412-263-1983.
First published on December 21, 2008 at 12:00 am
Source:? http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/08356/936646-113.stm
PICTURE Caption:?
A drilling rig used to bore thousands of feet into the earth to extract natural gas from the Marcellus Shales deep underground is seen on the hill above the pond on John Dunn's farm in Houston, Pa., in October.
[View Less]
WVWN 2008 Winter Meeting
Free Everyone Welcome
“Riparian Areas Resources and Strategies”
Wednesday, December 3, 2008
Lakeview Resort, Morgantown WV
AGENDA
10:00 – 10:20 Introduction , Tim Craddock, WV Save Our Streams
Tim will describe the connection between riparian buffers, water quality, and the ecological integrity of streams.
10:20 – 11:20 Funding Panel Discussion – …
[View More]Facilitated by Alvan Gale
q Wildlife Habitat Incentive Program, Bill O’Donnell, NRCS WHIP Program Manager
q Conservation Reserve Enhancement Program, Kevin Hinkle USDA Farm Service Agency
q Partners for Fish and Wildlife, John Schmidt , USFWS
q Mining Mitigation, Dennis Stottlemeyer, WV DEP Mining and Reclamaiton
q Transportation and Enhancement, Bill Robinson, WV DOT
11:20 – 11:30 BREAK
The afternoon sessions will be presentations from project organizers outlining the following:
q Planning
q Design
q Implementation
q Monitoring and Maintenance
q Lessons Learned – what did not work and things to consider such as planting times, manpower needed, availability of trees, laying out the site
11:30 – Noon Sleepy Creek Riparian Planting, Gale Foulds, Sleepy Creek WSA and Barbie Elliott, WV Conservation Agency
Noon – 1:00 LUNCH on your own
C2
1:00 – 1:30 Riparian Area Electric Fencing Demonstration, Neil Gillies, Cacapon Institute
1:30 – 2:00 Wardensville Project, Carla Hardy, WV Conservation Agency
2:00 – 2:10 BREAK
2:10 – 2:40 Mining Reforestation, Scott Eggerud, DEP DMR
2:45 – 3:10 Group Discussion on Lessons Learned – Facilitated by Rick Buckley
3:10 – 3:15 Evaluations and Wrap Up
[View Less]
This story suggests that PA-DEP first became aware of the problem on Oct. 10 due to air violations at Hatfields Ferry. But the report Duane circulated illustrates spikes at California, Charleroi, and Belle Vernon, PA. All of these are welll downstream of Hatfields Ferry? The story says MUB has rejected brine from gas drillers, so where is the high TDS coming from?
JBK
State Needs to Plan for Gas Well Drilling Brine
Posted Thursday, November 20, 2008 ; 01:50 PM
A long-term plan for gas …
[View More]well drilling water disposal may be one outcome of this fall's water quality problem on the Monongahela River in Pennsylvania.
Story by Pam Kasey
Email | Bio | Other Stories by Pam Kasey
MORGANTOWN -- A long-term plan for gas well drilling water disposal may be one outcome of this fall's water quality problem on the Monongahela River in Pennsylvania.
Environmental regulators need to anticipate how much brine the coming boom in Marcellus shale gas well drilling will generate and how much of that the rivers can handle, according to one scientist.
All Connected
The Monongahela River problem first came to the attention of Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection officials Oct. 10, explained PADEP Aquatic Biologist Supervisor Rick Spear at a Nov. 14 Morgantown meeting of agency officials, researchers, nonprofit groups and residents from both Pennsylvania and West Virginia.
On Oct. 10, Spear said, Allegheny Energy's Hatfield's Ferry Power Station violated its air emissions permit.
What followed is a study in how everything is connected.
The power station's problem, it turned out, originated in the cooling water it withdrew from the Monongahela River: Unusually high levels of the salts that, with other substances, make up the contaminant "total dissolved solids" (TDS).
TDS is not a human health hazard but, at concentrations above the Pennsylvania water quality standard of 500 milligrams/liter, it can harm industrial equipment and affect the smell and taste of drinking water, officials said.
PADEP asked the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to increase releases from dams upriver in West Virginia to dilute the contaminants.
And the Corps called the West Virginia Division of Natural Resources, which manages the facilities at Tygart Lake State Park.
Tygart Lake, it turns out, is on drought watch. Releasing much more from the dam would leave the boat ramps high and dry.
"That's going to affect our fishing," said DNR Fisheries Biologist Frank Jernejcic at the meeting. "This potentially has a lot of ramifications, not only for water quality but for access areas and other things."
PADEP stepped up its water quality sampling and found concentrations above 900 mg/L below wastewater treatment plants on the Monongahela River in Pennsylvania.
They traced it to gas well drilling brine the plants had accepted but could not, with standard technology, fully treat.
By Oct. 22, PADEP ordered nine wastewater treatment plants on the Monongahela River to curtail gas well drilling brine treatment until further notice.
Did West Virginia Contribute?
An outstanding question concerns October data showing TDS levels as high as 500 mg/L as the Monongahela River entered Pennsylvania from West Virginia.
The main problem was not in West Virginia, according to Paul Ziemkiewicz, director of the West Virginia Water Research Institute at West Virginia University.
PADEP's sampling data show clearly that the TDS numbers spiked at the wastewater treatment plants, Ziemkiewicz said.
Still, some wonder whether the West Virginia TDS numbers are unusually high for this time of year and, if so, whether that's due to low flows or to some new upriver discharge.
Historical data are not immediately available, but Ziemkiewicz said he's very interested in getting them.
Management Options
Here's why.
The Marcellus shale natural gas boom has only just begun.
PADEP's Spear estimated that there are 50 to 150 Marcellus gas wells in operation in Pennsylvania and said that the number is projected to increase "dramatically."
Just one company operating in West Virginia, Chesapeake Energy Corp., expects to drill 30 to 40 Marcellus wells in 2009, primarily in Wetzel County, according to vice president Scott Rotruck.
Drillers in West Virginia typically inject their brine deep underground or send it out of state.
But this fall's incident made it clear that even out-of-state discharges can have effects in West Virginia.
Ziemkiewicz suggested a near-term management option.
"We'll need to start looking at whether you can manage some of these discharges to the river," he said, "by simply encouraging people to discharge during high flow periods and to stop when river gets low, on a voluntary basis. That's something that could happen right away."
But more importantly, for longer-term planning, Ziemkiewicz is considering a research project that would use historical flow and water quality data to calculate how much brine the rivers can dilute.
Regulators need to think now about how much drilling brine they can expect in the coming years, he said. If they know how much the rivers will be able to handle, they can plan better for volumes above that.
Specialized treatment is one possibility.
Morgantown Utility Board General Manager James Green said MUB has rejected water from gas well drillers.
"They're talking to engineers right now about building a plant that's focused directly on treating this brine," Green said.
At the Nov. 14 meeting, Jernejcic said he joined DNR in the 1970s, "before the fish" -- that is, back when the Monongahela River was almost completely dead because of acid mine drainage. It now supports prized fisheries and continues to improve.
He wants to see planning for gas well drilling brine happen now.
Copyright 2008 West Virginia Media. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
>>> <Duane330(a)aol.com> 11/22/08 1:08 PM >>>
RE: High TDS in Mon River.
See the attachment for the Report of the
WVU Water Research Institute on the Mon River.
Duane
p.s. This report is also accessible from the home site
of the Upper Monongahela River Association under the
Marsellus Shale topic:
_www.uppermon.org_ (http://www.uppermon.org)
**************One site has it all. Your email accounts, your social networks,
and the things you love. Try the new AOL.comtoday!(http://pr.atwola.com/promoclk/100000075x1212962939x1200825291/aol?re…
%26icid=aolcom40vanity%26ncid=emlcntaolcom00000001)
[View Less]
RE: High TDS in Mon River.
See the attachment for the Report of the
WVU Water Research Institute on the Mon River.
Duane
p.s. This report is also accessible from the home site
of the Upper Monongahela River Association under the
Marsellus Shale topic:
_www.uppermon.org_ (http://www.uppermon.org)
**************One site has it all. Your email accounts, your social networks,
and the things you love. Try the new AOL.comtoday!(http://pr.atwola.com/promoclk/100000075x1212962939x1200825291/aol?re…
%26icid=aolcom40vanity%26ncid=emlcntaolcom00000001)
To: CLEAR members and friends.......................
It is proposed that CLEAR purchase a portable meter that measures Electrical
Conductivity (EC)
and pH for use on Cheat Lake and the local feeder streams. This will be
particularly valuable
during times of low flow, when there are releases of pollutants upstream or
when the local feeder
streams are suspected of contamination of the Lake. [We already have a
turbidity meter that
I have been using as has Mike Strager, our VP.]
We …
[View More]have enough money on hand. And, we have $2000 of credit with the Mon Co.
Commission
for reimbursement after expenditures, much of which is to be used for
educational programs
dealing with recreation in the Cheat Lake Park and Trail.
PROPOSED PURCHASE A.S.A.P
Page 362, Cole Parmer, 2009/2010 Catalog:
Oakton Waterproof Multiparameter Testr 35-Series Pocket Meter Package:
Catalog number ED-35425-00………..EC & pH Multi-Pocket Meter………………………
.$125.
Catalog number ED-35425-50……….Replacement module…………………………..$67.
Catalog number ED-09377-16……….Replacement batteries (pack of 6)……………
..$13.50
Catalog number ED-35624-70………..Hard carry case & pH pouches…………………$31.70
Total………………………………………………………………………………………$237.20
PLEASE LET ME KNOW IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS, CONCERNS, OBJECTIONS OR
ALTERNATIVES. THANK YOU.
Duane Nichols, 599-8040, Cell: 304-216-5535.
_duane330(a)aol.com_ (mailto:duane330@aol.com)
**************Get the Moviefone Toolbar. Showtimes, theaters, movie news &
more!(http://pr.atwola.com/promoclk/100000075x1212774565x1200812037/aol?red…p://toolbar.aol.com/moviefone/download.html?ncid=emlcntusdown00000001)
[View Less]