To the Energy Committee:
 
As we start to look at power plant closures, the issue of "reliability" of the electric power supply is likely to be raised as an excuse to keep these plants open.  I fear that, instead of closing old inefficient plants, the utilities will push for dramatic rate increases to install scrubbers, and that our "Friends of Coal" legislators will do whatever it takes to support that goal.  You will certainly here stories of the California energy crisis of 1999-2000 when blackouts and brownouts were threatened.  You will almost certainly NOT hear that this "crisis" was almost entirely manufactured by ENRON and that the "crisis" was averted almost exclusively through the use of efficiency mandates.  By switching to a "time of use" metering, consumers were charged extra for using electricity during peak periods, and responded almost overnight by shifting much of their electricity use to off-peak hours. 
 
As new air rules are implemented, we need to be ready to respond quickly.  The attached new report, and the press release below, identify an over-looked linkage between air regulatory and electric rate regulatory agencies.  Certainly, West Virginia DEP does not consider efficiency as a viable alternative to pollution controls or look at it as an alternative to new power plants.  The report documents that energy efficiency programs can both lower electric rates and reduce air pollution much more cheaply than new capacity.  Please read it carefully.
 
I suggest that this report is a vehicle to begin that debate with both WV-DEP and the Public Service Commission. 
 
Whaddya Tink?
 
Jim Kotcon

>>> Bill Price <bill.price@sierraclub.org> 1/31/2012 7:33 PM >>>
For those who want the actual report, see the PDF file attached.

On Tue, Jan 31, 2012 at 7:18 PM, Jim Sconyers <jimscon@gmail.com> wrote:
If you get a copy of the report please forward it. To get it requires more personal info than I wanted to give.

On Tue, Jan 31, 2012 at 1:10 PM, Bill Price <bill.price@sierraclub.org> wrote:

Energy Efficiency Is the Right Track for Clean Air

Energy Efficiency Should Be a Compliance Strategy for States and Utilities to Cost Effectively Achieve the Goals of Federal Air Regulations

Washington, D.C. (January 31, 2012): A new report by the American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy (ACEEE) reveals how energy efficiency can be used by states, policymakers, and utilities developing compliance strategies to meet the goals of federal air regulations. As mandated under the Clean Air Act, a suite of upcoming air regulations will impose limits on the emissions of multiple air pollutants. The report, entitled Energy Efficiency: The Slip Switch to a New Track Toward Compliance with Federal Air Regulations (http://aceee.org/research-report/e122), maps opportunities in these new regulations where energy efficiency can be used as a compliance tool.

"Although energy efficiency is our cheapest, cleanest, and quickest energy resource, it has often been ignored as a strategy for compliance with air regulations. But now the political, economic, and regulatory environments have aligned. We are on the threshold of a unique opportunity, a tipping point for energy efficiency," said Sara Hayes, ACEEE Senior Policy Analyst and lead author of the report.

"We selected major opportunities where energy efficiency can have a big impact. We unearthed a collection of good stories about what has already been tried and we found that there are some very promising opportunities. Energy efficiency can play a major role in regulations like the Cross-State Air Pollution Rule (CSAPR), the National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS), and multiple federal permitting rules," said Rachel Young, Research Analyst ACEEE and coauthor of the report.

This report is the second in the "Path to Compliance" series by ACEEE that outlines a track for the U.S. to transition to a cleaner, more reliable energy future. The first paper in this series, Avoiding a Train Wreck: Replacing Old Coal Plants with Energy Efficiency (http://www.aceee.org/white-paper/avoiding-a-train-wreck), explains that energy efficiency is a low-cost approach to reducing air pollution. The analysis shows that energy efficiency can be deployed much more quickly than a new power plant can be constructed and explains how energy efficiency is America's greatest untapped energy resource with massive potential.

"In our current economic climate, states and utilities need a cost-effective solution to reducing pollution, complying with EPA regulations, and maintaining reliable electricity for customers. The recommendations in this report will help to reduce emissions at the lowest cost," said Steven Nadel, Executive Director of ACEEE.


--

Bill Price, Organizing Representative

Sierra Club

Environmental Justice Program

Beyond Coal to Clean Energy Campaign

Phone: 304-389-8822 (Cell)

Email: bill.price@sierraclub.org





--
Jim Sconyers
jimscon@gmail.com
304.698.9628

Remember, Mother Nature bats last.



--

Bill Price, Organizing Representative

Sierra Club

Environmental Justice Program

Beyond Coal to Clean Energy Campaign

Phone: 304-389-8822 (Cell)

Email: bill.price@sierraclub.org