CHEAT CANYON LITIGATION UPDATE
Litigation between Allegheny Wood Products (AWP) and Friends
of Blackwater, West Virginia Sierra Club, and Cheat Lake Environment and
Recreation Association has been rescheduled. The case will open on November 14th
in Wheeling, WV. AWP has agreed not to restart logging operations in the Cheat
Canyon until there is a ruling.
The Endangered Species Act stipulates
that whenever an activity will result in the disturbance (killing) of federally
listed endangered species the company responsible for the disturbance must file
for an "incidental take permit". This requires that a Habitat Conservation Plan
(HCP) be prepared and approved. This does not prevent the activity from
occurring, but does insure that steps will be taken to protect the habitat of an
endangered species.
AWP makes the unlikely claim that they can log the
Cheat Canyon without disturbing the Cheat three-tooth snail, and therefore they
need not prepare an HCP. They base their position on a very questionable study
in which snails were searched for in late fall, during the dormant part of their
life cycle. The plaintiffs dispute this and want the endangered species act
enforced. They believe that there is habitat consistent with the snail
throughout the Canyon, particularly the river right bank below Even Nastier
Rapid, which is where AWP plans to log next.
The three environmental
organizations have paid for an extensive Cheat Snail Habitat Study and have
excellent pro-bono representation. However, they are short of funds to pay
travel costs and other expenses of their lawyers. Attorney Josh Barrett (from
Charleston) and Eric Glitzenstein and Erin Tobin (from Washington, DC) have
traveled extensively to take depositions and participate in pretrial
conferences. They will need to travel to Wheeling for up to three days in
November. They have prepared a strong case. Your continued support is
needed.
Please make checks payable to "CLEAR" with the notation "Cheat
Snail Project" and sent to:
Donna Weems, Treasurer
Cheat Lake
Environment &Recreation Association
320 Dream Catcher
Circle
Morgantown, WV 26508